The strong rushing performance against the Cleveland Browns always felt too good to be true, and the New Orleans Saints came crashing back down to earth on Sunday. Firing T.J. Paganetti and swapping Kendre Miller for Audric Estime provided immediate results coming out of the bye. The next goal was proving Week 9 wasn’t a fluke, but that’s exactly what it was.
The Saints were once again the poor rushing team we’ve seen for most of the year, and it was almost as bad as the deplorable effort versus the Steelers. The only thing that saved it was Shough’s scrambles. That’s a fool’s gold game and a bye week sandwiched between two of the worst rushing performances of the year.
After Estime led the team with 72 yards against the Browns a week ago, the team failed to reach 50 yards as a team versus the Panthers. The Saints recorded 24 yards on 17 designed runs, and Etienne and Estime averaged less than 2 yards per carry on 15 carries. It was a putrid performance that felt much like their trip to Paris.
Let’s not kid ourselves on where Saints run game deficiencies start
Firing Paganetti never felt like the true fix because run game coordinator is a small fish position and moving on from Paganetti wasn’t going to fix the offensive line. Brendan Nugent is the offensive line coach and the leader of the run game. He stayed on staff, so it’s no surprise this regression to the norm happened, especially since the struggles largely derive from the offensive line.
It's always been the offensive line who have spearheaded the struggles in the run game. Injuries to Erik McCoy and Taliese Fuaga just made a bad situation worse. The unit was already struggling prior to those injuries, but the right side of the line of scrimmage being manned by reserves was blatantly obvious on the fourth down attempt.
Meanwhile, Paganetti landed on his feet without having to even wait until the offseason. He returned to Philadelphia in the same role. The Eagles aren't having a great season either, but Paganetti had to have a smirk on his face seeing the Saints fall flat after being scapegoated as the hindrance to progress.
It looked like the Saints figured it out for a week, but in the end, it was what we always thought. The Saints are deeply flawed rushing team, and getting rid of a coach who's role wasn't even on this team before hiring him was never going to fix it.
