Skip to main content

The conversation around Tyler Shough is starting to get out of hand

ByDarrion Gray
New Orleans Saints quarterback Tyler Shough
New Orleans Saints quarterback Tyler Shough | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Tyler Shough should still be viewed as the quarterback of the future for the New Orleans Saints. That’s a belief that was suddenly questioned on social media, media personalities and fans alike, after Sunday’s loss to the Carolina Panthers. Second truth, Shough played poorly, and it’s okay to admit that. 

The former is a bit of an overstatement that feels largely rooted in confirmation bias and void of context on the Saints current situation. He’s a second round pick, who many didn’t believe in when he was drafted, so it is expected that these doubts would come up if Shough hit a rough patch early in his career. Now that it’s here, the mock drafts with a quarterback or breakdowns of if he’s truly a franchise quarterback were inevitable. 

That conclusion doesn’t take into account for how bad things are around Shough and have been for the majority of the year. The best stretches of offense when he just goes out, and he’s have to do it without great blocking, offensive scheme or a running game with a pulse. Shough has spent most of his pro career showing what he can do in spite of things not being the best around him, so hearing he’s proving the Saints need to look for a new franchise QB feels rash. 

Dear Saints fans, we can criticize Tyler Shough and still believe

These are the reasons fans find it hard to criticize Shough, but absolving him of all criticism is just as far from the truth as saying he’s not a franchise quarterback based off a couple games. 

The truth is Shough played poorly on Sunday, and we may be talking about a true two game slump if it weren’t for a clutch finish vs the Browns. 

Against the Panthers, it looked like the things we credited Shough for playing through finally took a toll on him, and the result was passiveness and ugly football. He looked antsy in the pocket and rushed even when he had time to stand and deliver in the pocket. Jaelan Phillips made his presence felt early, and it seemed to leave an impression on Shough

Shough is going to have to improve, but it's important to note that bad games happen. This was one of them. It's the first time the young quarterback seemed legitimately rattled in a long time.

Some of the turnovers have begun to pop up, and without those strong finishes, the inefficiencies of Shough and the offense are magnified. If Shough continues to play it safe with quick check downs and uneasiness in the pocket, then we can have a conversation.

Until then, can we all just be normal about Shough? He's going to struggle, but it isn't time to hit the panic button. If this level of play from the last month or so continues, then we're firmly in sophomore slump conversations, but even that doesn't mean to punt on the expirement.

Add us as a preferred source on Google