The New Orleans Saints let go of Justin Reid in a fashion strangely reminiscent of how the team moved on from Brandin Cooks last year, all the way down the day it happened. Cooks and Reid were both veterans and team captains who requested and were granted their releases in a surprise move. Both players were also released on Nov 19.
Two team captains requesting to be released by the team and back to back years isn’t necessarily the best of looks, but to shoot Kellen Moore, some blame, and this may be the last time that happens, it isn’t a culture issue that led to these releases. Reid and Cooks’ exits were more about usage than culture. Cooks never developed a role in the Saints offense, and Reid was reportedly about to see his role on defense diminish even further after already taking a step down last week.
Blame Moore for the former, as finding any role for Cooks was on him, but Reid’s departure came down to talent and his refusal to take a lesser role. That doesn’t mean the Saints fully escape blame for how these moves were handled. Mickey Loomis has to take blame for the poor execution.
Saints waited too long to get rid of Brandin Cooks and Justin Reid
Cooks and Reid were discussed as potential trade targets around the trade deadline, making their releases much more frustrating. Cooks was released two weeks post deadline, and Reid was cut a week and a half after it. The worst part is nothing changed in that time in between.
Cooks didn’t have a role for the entire season. Reid hasn't played up to expectation since signing his contract, and his lack of notable playmaking from Year 1 was paired with notable mistakes. That's been a constant throughout the season.
The Saints cut Reid's snaps the game after the trade deadline. There was a clear displeasure with his performance, and that's when the Saints should have dealt Reid.
Granted, it takes two to tango, but it's hard to imagine the Saints couldn't have recouped a mid to late round pick for Cooks or Reid. Loomis should have been more aggressive in looking a trade partner rather than cutting them right afer the deadline.
That's poor handling of a player who's either unused or you're dissatisfied with. Most times deals don't go through because one side is unhappy with the compensation on the table or how much one side is asking for. If it's the latter, the Saints should have humbled themselves and adjusted the asking price because walking away with nothing worst the last option.
