With Justin Reid out of the picture, the New Orleans Saints had the perfect opportunity to put Jonas Sanker back in his natural position. Instead, Brandon Staley opted to replace Reid with Jordan Howden. The logic makes sense on the surface, but a deeper dive shows a missed opportunity.
Reid has seen his snaps dwindled over the past couple of weeks, and Howden has been the one to fill in for him during that time. It should have been expected that the Saints would follow the same protocol with Reid, however, expected doesn't mean correct.
That is no shot at Howden, as he could go and play well, but it just feels like the ceiling was higher choosing Sanker to take over Reid's position. Howden could play well enough to close the season to make this a moot point. Still, Sanker being a piece who could be here for the foreseeable future heightens
Jonas Sanker should be the Saints safety of the future
The Saints are more than likely going to need at least one safety this offseason. That was true before Reid was released, and that doesn't change with Howden starting. It's just an extremely uphill batle with the amount of games left.
Sanker would have had the same tiemetable, but he would have had two things working in his favor: past experience and contract. Howden is in the final year of his contract, while Sanker has two years after 2026 left on his rookie deal. The latter was just also more impressive playing deep than Howden has been in his career.
Simply put, Sanker had a better chance of answering the Saints safety question before the offseason even rolled around. His rookie year showed he was ready for the moment, and his downhill, physical play style lending itself to the position is more than just theoretical. Sanker is best suited as the safety of the future, and this could be the period where that's decided for him.
The Saints moving Sanker back to safety, which we have explored before, would impact multiple positions, but it wouldn't be much of a curve for Sanker. It'd just be returning to a normal spot for him, so it's not a major transition that would prove disruptive. The Saints don't want to go that route.
Staley didn't completely shut down the possibility of Sanker eventually taking over for Reid, but he still never opened the door to Sanker leaving the STAR role. Instead, Staley told reporters Sanker playing safety in base defense and STAR in nickel defense is something they'd consider later down the line. It's exactly what they did with Alontae Taylor last year.
That strategy is once again something that sounds good until you take a deeper dive into it. The second year player's snap count this year shows how often the defense is in nickel, so even if Sanker does go to playing safety in base packages, he'll still spend the majority of his time at STAR. Those who want Sanker is his natural position would remain unsatisfied.
The other aspect is the Saints like Sanker at STAR, with Staley mentioning Sanker is coming off one of his best games., so there would be no reason for them to feel the need to move him. It does feel like Sanker is serviceable in the slot. He isn't standing out as a liability, but he was more of a playmaker as a rookie.
