Are the New Orleans Saints Players in the cradle of industrial due process?

Use your ← → (arrows) to browse

Aug 5, 2011; Canton, OH; USA; NFL commissioner Roger Goodell (left) and NFLPA executive director Demaurice Smith sign the new CBA in front of the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Mandatory Credit: Andrew Weber-US PRESSWIRE


Contrary to popular belief, NFL players are not without recourse when it comes to league discipline.  They, under the CBA and labor law, are afforded industrial due process.

Although industrial due process (IDP) is different from Constitutional due process, it has elements that, if adhered to, provide protection against unfair employer investigations.

Vilma’s legal team and the NFPA (on behalf of Fujita, Hargrove and Smith) are both asserting this defense in their lawsuits against the NFL.

The NFLPA’s brief sets out the elements succinctly as follows:  (See links to NFLPA and Vilma suits below)

1. Since the charges were made, the NFLPA, on behalf of the Players, has tried to utilize the procedures set forth in the CBA to ensure that the Players were afforded a fair process in the appropriate forum to defend themselves against the extremely serious and false accusations made against them.

2. (i) the NFL violated express CBA requirements and refused to provide the Players with access to critical documents or witnesses, or anything resembling the fairness mandated by the CBA and governing industrial due process law … (iii) the CBA’s System Arbitrator possesses exclusive jurisdiction to arbitrate … the “pay-for-performance” conduct charged here, and that jurisdiction was improperly usurped by the Commissioner, whom the NFLPA never agreed could serve as arbitrator under such circumstances.

Use your ← → (arrows) to browse
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: CBA Industrial Due Process Jonathan Vilma NFL NFLPA Roger Goodell Saints Bounty Will Smith


    Excellent article.
    I can only hope the best for our players who’s names have been dragged through the shit heap.

    • louisianakid1954

      DARKTHRONE; This sounds like some undercover mess by the NFL I be glad when the truth is in the open and team name is cleared. We have been really hurted by this mess but DARKTHRONE we must win this Super Bowl Championship do you believe in miracle if not you’re getting ready to see one in 2013 the Saints are the dream team we on our way I’m in Dallas, Tx. I need some Saints flags for my car give me some ideas.